Balistreri Brothers Pizza

Reviews about Balistreri Brothers Pizza

• 1 / 5

  By CPL PUNISHMENT
  Trust me... Go to Pizzaria Scotty down the street.This Thin crust is not thin crispy crust we all know and love here is Wisconsin. There is a severe lack of sauce that makes it taste like dough, cheese, and whatever topping you have. The dough, cheese, and toppings don't taste right...like they are very cheap ingredients. This place offers your choice of canned or fresh mushrooms...I worked at a pizza place that made pizza from scratch, and NEVER heard of the option of canned topping anything , as this is cheap and disgusting. The garlic bread is a soggy piece of Italian bread cut in half, disgusting. The chef boyardee pizza kit tastes better then this...
  January 08, 2017
• 1 / 5

  By karen kolasa
  We ordered delivery today and was told it'd be an hour. An hour and 15 minutes go by and nothing. We called and told it was on it's way. 20 more minutes and finally it arrived (we live 5 minutes from the place - so we regret not just doing pick up). The delivery person told us the total which seemed high. We were never told the total on the phone. She explained that even though we ordered 3 different toppings on each side (when we noted on the phone we wanted a 3 topping pizza with each half with their own toppings), we were charged for actually 6 toppings. We were upset and she said when she'd get back she'd have the girl in charge call us to discuss. We never got a call and she kept the receipt! We were going to run out and get it from her but she was driving out from our driveway quickly. I found out you can order on their site and guess what? You can order 3 toppings on a half and they don't charge anything additional if they're different toppings on the other half. Overall, horrible customer service on first impression and seems this is their reputation based in other reviews. Food was not good enough for us to look past being ripped off and poor customer service. Won't be eating at again.
  June 16, 2016